
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for families, couples, or groups who want on-site dining, a full spa (Poseidon Spa), and a heated outdoor pool with a children's pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a landmark, full-service historic resort in downtown St. Augustine with multiple restaurants, a full spa, and family-friendly amenities. 44 Spanish Street Inn is an adults-only historic-district bed & breakfast for travelers who want a small, centrally located, quieter stay steps from St. George Street.
Updated · about 0.1 km apart

Best for families, couples, or groups who want on-site dining, a full spa (Poseidon Spa), and a heated outdoor pool with a children's pool.

Best for adults who want a compact, intimate inn right in the historic district with complimentary full breakfast and easy walking access to downtown sights.
When Casa Monica wins: choose Casa Monica if you want more on-site facilities — multiple restaurants and bars, a full-service Poseidon Spa, a heated outdoor pool and children's pool, event/ballroom space, and shuttle/beach concierge services.
When 44 Spanish Street Inn wins: pick 44 Spanish Street Inn if you want an adults-only, small‑house experience in the historic district with very close walking access to St. George Street, Flagler College and other downtown attractions, plus a complimentary full breakfast.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the better fit for travelers who prioritize amenities, dining variety, spa services and family access; 44 Spanish Street Inn is a simple, quieter adults-only alternative for guests focused on location and a small‑inn atmosphere.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | 44 Spanish Street Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, historic full-service resort with event spaces and a lively lobby bar. | Adults-only historic bed & breakfast with a small, intimate feel. |
| Location (historic downtown) | Heart of historic downtown — steps from St. George Street and Flagler College. | |
| Size (rooms) | About 125–138 rooms and suites (sources vary). | 8 air-conditioned rooms. |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 (exceptions require guardian). | Adults-only property; guests under 18 not permitted (minimum check-in 21). |
| Pools / outdoor | Heated outdoor pool plus a separate children's pool and hot tub/Jacuzzi. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Starbucks/Café Cordova and Cobalt Lounge. | Complimentary full breakfast daily; no on-site restaurant or bar listed beyond breakfast. |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa on site with massages, facials, body treatments and nail services. | Not published |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking available (fee); resort fee includes beach shuttle & partner beach access. | Free self parking on site; front desk has limited hours. |
| Known for | Gilded‑Age landmark hotel with ballrooms and full-service amenities. | A quiet, adults-only inn right in the historic district with a complimentary full breakfast. |
| Typical guest | Families, couples, groups and event attendees seeking amenities and location. | Adults and couples seeking a small, central B&B experience. |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of historic downtown within steps of main sights.
Choose Casa Monica if you want a central downtown base with transport help to the beach.
44 Spanish Street Inn occupies a spot in the St. Augustine Historic District with very close walking access.
Choose 44 Spanish Street Inn if you want an adults-only stay a few steps from the main downtown attractions.
Casa Monica offers a wide range of guest rooms and suites across a large historic property.
Casa Monica suits travelers needing more room types, family suites, or accessible options.
44 Spanish Street Inn provides a very small set of air-conditioned rooms with a few upgraded options.
44 Spanish Street Inn is best if you want a compact, straightforward room selection in a B&B setting.
Casa Monica has several on-site dining and drinking options for different moods and occasions.
Pick Casa Monica for variety and late-night bar options in the hotel.
44 Spanish Street Inn focuses on a complimentary full breakfast and does not list full-service restaurants on site.
Choose 44 Spanish Street Inn if you plan to eat out in downtown and value a included breakfast each morning.
Casa Monica provides on-site outdoor pool facilities plus a beach concierge service.
Casa Monica is the clear option if pool access or beach shuttle services matter to you.
44 Spanish Street Inn's supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
If an on-site pool is important, 44 Spanish Street Inn likely won't meet that need based on published info.
Casa Monica provides a full spa, fitness center and an active lobby bar with live music on weekends.
Casa Monica is better for guests who want spa treatments, fitness facilities and evening entertainment on site.
44 Spanish Street Inn is positioned as a quieter adults-only property without published spa or nightlife offerings.
44 Spanish Street Inn is suited to travelers who prefer a low-key stay and will visit local bars or venues for nightlife.

Casa Monica — pools, children's pool, suites and event space accommodate families and groups.

44 Spanish Street Inn — adults-only policy and compact B&B setting right in the historic district.

Casa Monica — on-site Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms and full-service offerings.

44 Spanish Street Inn — very small property steps from St. George Street and major downtown sights.
Both are in the historic district and within a very short walk of St. George Street and Flagler College; pick either for walkable access.
Choose Casa Monica for the on-site Poseidon Spa. 44 Spanish Street Inn does not publish an on-site spa.
No — 44 Spanish Street Inn is adults-only and does not permit guests under 18. Casa Monica welcomes children of all ages.
44 Spanish Street Inn offers a complimentary full breakfast daily. Casa Monica offers breakfast on property for a fee (typical price noted in hotel materials).
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·