
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want historic architecture, a full-service spa (Poseidon Spa), and downtown walkability right outside the door.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a historic, full-service landmark hotel in downtown St. Augustine with on-site dining, a spa and pool — best for travelers who want a characterful, amenity-rich base within steps of St. George Street. Hilton Garden Inn St. Augustine Historic District is a familiar Hilton-branded midscale hotel in the Historic District — best for travelers who prefer predictable chain amenities, accessible rooms, and straightforward value near downtown.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want historic architecture, a full-service spa (Poseidon Spa), and downtown walkability right outside the door.

Best for travelers who want a reliable, accessible Hilton-brand property with straightforward rooms, free Wi-Fi (included in amenities), and an outdoor pool close to downtown attractions.
When Casa Monica Resort & Spa wins: Choose Casa Monica if you want historic character, larger signature event and wedding spaces, a full-service spa (Poseidon Spa) and restaurants like Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar within the hotel — and if you want to be steps from Flagler College and St. George Street.
When Hilton Garden Inn St. Augustine Historic District wins: Choose the Hilton Garden Inn if you prefer the predictability of a national Hilton property, need specific accessible room types (several roll-in / mobility-accessible rooms listed), or want a simpler midscale option with a small outdoor pool and fitness facilities.
Bottom line: Both hotels put you in or near St. Augustine’s historic core; pick Casa Monica for history, dining and spa amenities and larger event spaces, or pick the Hilton Garden Inn for a dependable, accessible, midscale stay with easy access to downtown points of interest.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Hilton Garden Inn St. Augustine Historic District |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Gilded-Age landmark with Moorish-revival details and boutique full-service resort amenities. | Clean, midscale Hilton property with straightforward rooms and a practical, family-friendly layout. |
| Location (to St. George Street / Flagler College) | About a 1-minute walk to Flagler College and steps from St. George Street. | In Uptown St. Augustine; within a short drive or roughly 0.8 mi (1.4 km) of St. George Street. |
| Size (rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary). | 83 guestrooms. |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, adjacent hot tub/Jacuzzi, and a children's pool. | One outdoor pool (wheelchair-accessible). |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Café/Starbucks and Cobalt Lounge nearby. | On-site restaurant (full breakfasts available for a fee) and 1 restaurant noted; bar/lounge options not individually named in listing. |
| Spa / wellness | Poseidon Spa on-site with massages, facials, body treatments, hair & nail services and a Quiet Room. | Fitness center and wellness facilities; no on-site full-service spa published in the supplier listing. |
| Known for | Historic architecture, wedding and ballroom event spaces, downtown walkability. | Hilton-branded predictability, multiple accessible room types, and accessible public spaces. |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair-accessible paths, registration desk, pool and fitness center; accessible rooms available. | |
| Parking & transfers | Valet parking (surcharge); resort fee includes shuttle/ beach concierge access; electric vehicle charging available on property. | Self parking (surcharge) and on-site parking; electric car charging station listed. |
| Family friendliness | All-ages resort with children's pool and family-friendly dining; children 18 and under stay free sharing existing bedding. | |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic downtown within immediate walking distance of Flagler College and St. George Street.
Choose Casa Monica if you want to walk to the historic core and downtown attractions from your hotel.
Hilton Garden Inn St. Augustine Historic District is in the Uptown/downtown area, offering a short drive or longer walk into the busiest historic blocks.
Choose the Hilton Garden Inn for a convenient downtown-adjacent location with easier vehicle access and parking options.
Casa Monica offers a mix of historic-style rooms and multi-bedroom suites with period details and modern amenities.
Choose Casa Monica when you want suites, characterful rooms or larger accommodations for groups/families.
Hilton Garden Inn provides standard Hilton-style guest rooms with a selection of accessible room types and balcony options.
Choose the Hilton for predictable room layouts and a wide selection of dedicated accessible room types.
Casa Monica has multiple on-site dining outlets anchored by Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar plus poolside and café options.
Pick Casa Monica if in-hotel dining variety and a signature chophouse matter to your stay.
Hilton Garden Inn lists one on-site restaurant with breakfast available for a fee and standard hotel dining offerings.
Pick the Hilton if you want simple, reliable hotel dining and don’t need multiple signature restaurants on-site.
Casa Monica provides a heated outdoor pool, hot tub/Jacuzzi and a separate children's pool, plus beach concierge access.
Choose Casa Monica for family-friendly pool options and included beach access services.
Hilton Garden Inn lists a single outdoor pool and standard outdoor seating areas.
Choose the Hilton if you only need a basic outdoor pool and easy access to downtown attractions.
Casa Monica features the Poseidon Spa and an active lobby/lounge scene with live music on weekends.
Pick Casa Monica for an on-site spa and more evening lounge entertainment in a historic setting.
Hilton Garden Inn emphasizes fitness facilities and accessible public spaces rather than a full-service spa or nightly live entertainment.
Pick the Hilton if you prioritize fitness access and practical amenities over an on-site spa or evening live music.

Casa Monica — original 1888 architecture, Moorish-revival details and period public rooms.

Hilton Garden Inn — multiple roll-in and mobility-accessible room types and standard Hilton layouts.

Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa with a menu of massages, facials, body treatments and nail services.

Hilton Garden Inn — a familiar brand with simple dining, fitness and an outdoor pool close to attractions.
Casa Monica is steps from Flagler College and St. George Street; Hilton Garden Inn is in Uptown and roughly 0.8 miles (1.4 km) from the main historic shopping strip.
Yes — Casa Monica has the on-site Poseidon Spa offering a full menu of treatments. The Hilton Garden Inn supplier listing does not publish an on-site full-service spa.
Yes. Casa Monica explicitly welcomes children and has a children's pool; Hilton Garden Inn is also not adults-only and lists family-friendly room types.
Casa Monica has extensive event and wedding space (multiple ballrooms and poolside venues) and is commonly used for weddings; the Hilton Garden Inn is a standard midscale hotel with more modest meeting space per the supplier listing.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·