
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want historic character, a full spa experience (Poseidon Spa), and family-friendly pool facilities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a landmark Gilded‑Age downtown St. Augustine resort with a full spa, family-friendly pools, and on‑site dining; read this if you want historic character, a spa day, or a central base for sightseeing. Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel is an upscale Marriott-affiliated downtown hotel with modern meeting space and one outdoor pool; read this if you want a recognizable Marriott product close to St. George Street and Castillo de San Marcos.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want historic character, a full spa experience (Poseidon Spa), and family-friendly pool facilities.

Best for travelers who want a modern, centrally located Marriott property with meeting space and straightforward downtown access.
When Casa Monica wins: Choose Casa Monica if you value historic architecture, an on‑site full-service spa (Poseidon Spa), a heated outdoor pool plus a separate children's pool, or multiple signature dining and event spaces in a landmark setting.
When Renaissance wins: Choose the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel if you prefer a smaller, Marriott-branded property with flexible conference/meeting rooms, a convenient single on‑site restaurant and bar, and a compact downtown location minutes from St. George Street and Castillo de San Marcos.
Bottom line: Both hotels sit in St. Augustine's historic core and put you within easy walking distance of major sights. Pick Casa Monica for character, spa services, and larger event/pool offerings; pick the Renaissance for a modern Marriott experience with ample meeting space in a smaller downtown footprint.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded‑Age landmark with period architecture, ornate public rooms and a resort feel | Upscale, modern Marriott property with contemporary public spaces and meeting focus |
| Location (historic downtown) | Steps from St. George Street, Flagler College and Lightner Museum | |
| Size (guest rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 89 guestrooms |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool plus a dedicated children's pool and hot tub; pool hours published | One outdoor pool (wheelchair-accessible) |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa — multi‑room full-service spa with treatments, nail salon and Quiet Room | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Café/Starbucks on site | Castillo Bar + Kitchen (restaurant) and a bar/lounge |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple ballrooms and outdoor pool‑deck venues totaling ~12,000 sq ft; large ballroom options | 5200 sq ft conference space with 6 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair‑accessible paths, accessible rooms and accessible pool; accessible fitness center | |
| Family friendliness | Welcomes children of all ages; children’s pool; children 18 and younger stay free in same room | |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (surcharge), resort fee includes shuttle to beach and beach concierge access | Covered and secured parking with valet option (surcharge); close to visitor center and trolley stops |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of historic downtown, within immediate walking distance of Flagler College and St. George Street.
Pick Casa Monica if you want the closest proximity to the key historic attractions and a full-service downtown resort experience.
Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel is also located in the Uptown historic core, a short walk to St. George Street and Castillo de San Marcos.
Pick the Renaissance if you want a centrally located Marriott option with easy access to downtown attractions and tour services.
Casa Monica offers a broad set of room and suite types across its historic property footprint.
Choose Casa Monica for larger suite choices and rooms with historic character.
The Renaissance offers 89 guestrooms with a mix of accessible room types and a few deluxe rooms with balconies.
Choose the Renaissance for a smaller, straightforward room offering with several accessible room formats.
Casa Monica has several on‑site dining options anchored by Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar.
Choose Casa Monica if you want more on‑site dining variety and a signature chophouse.
Renaissance features Castillo Bar + Kitchen as its primary dining outlet and a bar/lounge for evening drinks.
Choose the Renaissance if you want a single convenient on‑site restaurant and a compact dining footprint.
Casa Monica operates a heated outdoor pool, a dedicated children's pool and a hot tub, plus a beach concierge service.
Choose Casa Monica for a fuller pool offering and direct beach‑access services.
Renaissance has one outdoor pool listed among its public amenities.
Choose the Renaissance if a single outdoor pool in a downtown hotel meets your needs.
Casa Monica offers a full spa (Poseidon Spa) and an on‑site lounge with live entertainment on weekends.
Choose Casa Monica if spa treatments and on‑property evening entertainment are important to your stay.
Renaissance provides meeting‑room assistive features and a fitness center; nightlife is concentrated in downtown venues nearby.
Choose the Renaissance for a convenient fitness setup and quick access to downtown nightlife outside the hotel.

Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms, signature packages and a Quiet Room.

Renaissance — 5200 sq ft conference space and 6 meeting rooms suited for corporate events.

Casa Monica — Gilded‑Age landmark building and ornate public rooms that reflect St. Augustine history.

Renaissance — Marriott affiliation and a compact, modern downtown hotel layout.
Casa Monica — it has a dedicated children’s pool and family‑friendly programming; children 18 and younger stay free sharing existing bedding.
Both are in the historic downtown core and within an easy walk; they are roughly 0.2 km apart, so either provides quick access to St. George Street and nearby landmarks.
Not published — the Renaissance listing notes fitness and pool amenities but does not publish a full-service on‑site spa in the supplier listing.
Yes — both properties list multiple accessibility features including accessible paths, rooms and pools (with some limitations noted).
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·