
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want a landmark Gilded-Age hotel with a full-service spa, on-site restaurants and event spaces in the heart of the historic district.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a historic, full-service downtown St. Augustine resort with a spa and year-round heated pool; read this if you want a landmark hotel, on-site spa, and easy walking access to the city's main sights. Hotel Amalga ST. Augustine Tribute Portfolio is a smaller Marriott Tribute Portfolio property near Oyster Creek and Flagler College; read this if you want a compact, well-rated boutique option with Marriott soft-brand benefits.
Updated · about 0.6 km apart

Best for travelers who want a landmark Gilded-Age hotel with a full-service spa, on-site restaurants and event spaces in the heart of the historic district.

Best for guests who prefer a compact, well-rated Tribute Portfolio option with Marriott recognition, free Wi‑Fi and a simple downtown location near Flagler College.
When Casa Monica wins: pick Casa Monica if you want a historic property with a full-service Poseidon Spa, multiple dining venues (including Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar), larger event space and a heated outdoor pool plus a separate children's pool—good for families, spa-goers and people holding events or weddings.
When Hotel Amalga wins: choose Hotel Amalga if you prefer a smaller, boutique-feel hotel within the Marriott family that’s easy to work with, offers basic downtown comforts (free Wi‑Fi, 24-hour front desk, one outdoor pool) and a slightly simpler, lower-key stay.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the fuller-service, historic resort option with more on-site amenities and event capacity; Hotel Amalga is a solid, smaller Tribute Portfolio property for travelers who want downtown convenience and Marriott soft-brand consistency without the larger resort feature set.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Hotel Amalga ST. Augustine Tribute Portfolio |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded-Age landmark with Mediterranean/Moorish design and full-service resort amenities | Boutique-style Marriott Tribute property with a straightforward downtown feel |
| Location | In the heart of historic downtown — steps from Flagler College and St. George Street | |
| Size (rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 58 rooms |
| Guest rating / stars | Kessler/Marriott listings; 4-star resort (historic luxury positioning); Marriott/resort sources list as upscale | 3 stars · guest rating 8.8/10 (supplier listing) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool + children's pool; pool open year-round; poolside bar (Soltana) | One outdoor pool; pool sun loungers and umbrellas |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Starbucks/Café Cordova | Hugo's Restaurant (bar/lounge, ocean view noted in supplier highlights) and one coffee shop/cafe |
| Spa / wellness | Poseidon Spa — full-service, multiple treatment rooms, Moroccan-villa design | Not published |
| Event & wedding space | Large — ~10k–12k sq ft including Casa Monica Ballroom, Flagler Ballroom, Sultan's Pavilion and pool deck options | Not published |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly; children welcome; accessible paths, pool and public areas | Not adults-only; wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); accessible elevator and entrance |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (fee); resort fee covers all-day beach shuttle and beach concierge access | Covered and uncovered parking; secured parking; valet parking surcharge listed |
Casa Monica sits in the center of St. Augustine's historic district, steps from Flagler College and St. George Street.
Best choice if you want to be inside the historic district with most attractions within walking distance.
Hotel Amalga is in downtown St. Augustine (Oyster Creek), within walking distance of Flagler College and many historic sites.
A compact downtown location that keeps you close to the same attractions as Casa Monica but in a smaller property.
Casa Monica offers a wide range of rooms and suites (listed as 125–138 rooms depending on source) including multi-bedroom suites.
Choose Casa Monica for more room-type options and suites for families or groups.
Hotel Amalga has 58 air-conditioned rooms with Smart TVs and accessible-room types available.
A smaller, tidy room collection with several accessibility-focused room types and simple in-room amenities.
Casa Monica features multiple on-site outlets for full meals, cocktails and coffee.
Casa Monica provides more full-service dining choices and a signature restaurant for evenings.
Hotel Amalga provides a single main restaurant and a coffee shop/cafe on property.
Hotel Amalga covers basics well but has fewer on-site dining venues than Casa Monica.
Casa Monica operates a heated outdoor pool plus a separate children's pool and hot tub/Jacuzzi.
Good for families and guests who want a heated pool and on-site poolside service plus beach access via shuttle.
Hotel Amalga offers one outdoor pool with sun loungers and umbrellas.
A simple pool setup suitable for short stays and downtown downtime.
Casa Monica has a full-service Poseidon Spa and an on-site fitness center.
Casa Monica is the stronger pick for spa-focused travelers and those who want on-site evening entertainment.
Hotel Amalga provides basic guest services and a public lounge/restaurant but no published on-site spa.
Hotel Amalga suits travelers who plan to use downtown nightlife and attractions rather than on-site wellness facilities.

Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa, treatment packages and a larger wellness program.

Casa Monica — immediate access to Flagler College, Lightner Museum and St. George Street.

Hotel Amalga — Tribute Portfolio affiliation brings Marriott recognition and Bonvoy connectivity.

Hotel Amalga — smaller footprint and simpler on-site offerings make it an easy, no-frills downtown base.
Casa Monica — it has a dedicated children's pool and family-friendly room and dining options; children 18 and younger stay free when using existing bedding.
Casa Monica has the on-site Poseidon Spa. Hotel Amalga does not have a published on-site spa in the supplier listing.
Both are downtown and within a short walk of Flagler College and St. George Street; Casa Monica is directly adjacent to several landmarks.
Yes — Hotel Amalga is listed as a Marriott Tribute Portfolio hotel, which associates it with Marriott's soft-brand offerings and Bonvoy benefits.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·