
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for families and travelers who want on-site dining, a spa and pool options in a landmark Gilded-Age hotel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a full-service, historic landmark hotel in downtown St. Augustine with on-site restaurants, a family-friendly pool complex and a full-service Poseidon Spa. Carriage Way Centennial is a small, inn-style boutique property steps from St. George Street aimed at travelers who prefer a compact historic B&B experience; this guide helps you decide which fits your trip.
Updated · about 0.1 miles apart

Best for families and travelers who want on-site dining, a spa and pool options in a landmark Gilded-Age hotel.

Best for adults and couples who want a small, centrally located inn within steps of St. George Street and Flagler College.
When Casa Monica wins: Choose Casa Monica if you want multiple on-site restaurants and bars, a full-service spa (Poseidon Spa), a heated outdoor pool plus a children’s pool, event/wedding spaces, and easy access to a concierge-run beach shuttle and beach concierge services. It suits families, groups and guests who prefer resort conveniences in the historic district.
When Carriage Way Centennial wins: Choose Carriage Way Centennial if you prefer a smaller, quieter inn experience right in the heart of the historic district and value walking access to St. George Street and Flagler College. It’s a good pick for adults or couples who want a compact property with complimentary breakfast and immediate proximity to downtown attractions.
Bottom line: Both properties put you in downtown St. Augustine. Pick Casa Monica for resort amenities, spa services and family-friendly facilities; pick Carriage Way Centennial for a boutique, adults-focused downtown stay and a more intimate scale.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Carriage Way Centennial |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded-Age landmark resort with full-service amenities and event spaces | Small boutique inn/bed & breakfast in a historic downtown building |
| Location | Heart of historic downtown; steps from Flagler College and St. George Street | |
| Size | Large property with roughly 125–138 rooms and multiple suites | Very small property (9 air-conditioned rooms listed) |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; family-friendly (children stay free under 18 with existing bedding) | Adults-only property; guests under 21 are not permitted |
| Pools / water facilities | Heated outdoor pool, children’s pool, adjacent hot tub; pool hours published | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site outlets including Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, and an on-site Starbucks | No on-site restaurants listed; complimentary English breakfast served daily |
| Spa / wellness | Poseidon Spa on-site with multiple treatment rooms, massage, facials and packages | Not published |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (fee), beach shuttle/concierge service included in resort fee | Limited parking onsite and free parking nearby listed; no valet noted |
| Known for | Historic Gilded-Age architecture, wedding and event spaces, full-service resort amenities | Central, walkable downtown location and boutique inn atmosphere |
| Wi‑Fi & basics | Wi‑Fi included (part of resort fee); fitness center available | Complimentary WiFi and complimentary English breakfast |
Casa Monica sits at 95 Cordova St in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, within steps of Flagler College and St. George Street.
Choose Casa Monica for immediate access to downtown landmarks plus easy shuttle access to the beach.
Carriage Way Centennial is at 26 Cordova St, a few steps from St. George Street and Flagler College.
Pick Carriage Way Centennial if you want to be right in the middle of downtown walkability without resort-scale grounds.
Casa Monica offers a wide range of guest rooms and suites across a large historic property (roughly 125–138 rooms depending on source).
Casa Monica suits families and larger parties who need multiple-room options and accessible rooms.
Carriage Way Centennial lists 9 air-conditioned rooms with named room types (The Lapis Lazuli Room, The Jade Room, The Morganite Room, etc.).
Carriage Way Centennial is best if you want a small, individually named-room experience rather than many room categories.
Casa Monica has multiple on-site dining outlets covering meals, coffee and cocktails.
Casa Monica is the choice for on-site full meals, cocktails and quick coffee without leaving the property.
Carriage Way Centennial does not list a full restaurant on site but provides a complimentary English breakfast daily.
Carriage Way Centennial works well if you plan to eat out in downtown St. Augustine and want a simple breakfast included.
Casa Monica features a heated outdoor pool, a separate children’s pool and an adjacent hot tub/Jacuzzi.
If on-site pool time and beach shuttle services matter, Casa Monica provides clear, published options.
Carriage Way Centennial is a small downtown inn with no published on-site pool or spa.
Carriage Way Centennial is focused on downtown access and nearby activities rather than on-site pool facilities.
Casa Monica has an on-site Poseidon Spa, a fitness center and an in‑hotel lounge with weekend live music.
Choose Casa Monica when in‑house spa treatments, a fitness center and on-site evening entertainment matter to you.
Carriage Way Centennial provides a quiet downtown setting; spa and nightclub amenities are not published for the property.
Carriage Way Centennial suits guests who plan to use downtown venues for nightlife and book off-site wellness services.

Casa Monica — family-friendly pools, children’s pool and family room policies make it the better choice for kids.

Carriage Way Centennial — small, inn-style property steps from St. George Street and Flagler College.

Casa Monica — on-site Poseidon Spa with published treatments and hours.

Carriage Way Centennial — adults-only policy (guests under 21 are not permitted).
Both are centrally located on Cordova Street and put you within easy walking distance of St. George Street and Flagler College; they are only about 0.1 miles apart.
No on-site spa or pool is published for Carriage Way Centennial; nearby activities and tours are listed instead.
Carriage Way Centennial offers a complimentary English breakfast daily; Casa Monica offers a continental breakfast for a fee (typically around $15–$20 per person).
Casa Monica — it has multiple ballrooms and poolside venues with substantial event capacity; Carriage Way Centennial is a small inn without large event spaces published.
Yes — both are in the historic core of St. Augustine and within easy walking distance of many museums, the Castillo de San Marcos and other downtown attractions.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·