
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for families, events, and guests who want on-site dining, a full spa, and pool facilities in downtown St. Augustine.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a full-service, Gilded-Age landmark hotel in downtown St. Augustine with multiple restaurants, a heated outdoor pool, and the Poseidon Spa — good for families, event groups, and travelers who want downtown history with resort amenities. Bayfront Westcott House St Augustine B&B is a small, highly rated bayfront bed-and-breakfast in the historic district — best for couples or travelers who prioritize a quiet, boutique bayfront stay and a central walkable location.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for families, events, and guests who want on-site dining, a full spa, and pool facilities in downtown St. Augustine.

Best for travelers seeking a small, highly rated bayfront B&B within easy walking distance of St. George Street and downtown museums.
When Casa Monica Resort & Spa wins: Choose Casa Monica if you want resort-style amenities (heated outdoor pool, children’s pool, a full-service Poseidon Spa, multiple dining outlets, and larger event/wedding spaces) and easy access to downtown attractions with family-friendly services.
When Bayfront Westcott House St Augustine B&B wins: Choose Bayfront Westcott House if you prefer a small, intimate property with a direct bayfront setting, very high guest ratings, and the feel of a boutique bed-and-breakfast close to St. George Street.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is a full-service downtown resort that suits families and groups needing more on-site facilities; Bayfront Westcott House is a compact, highly rated bayfront B&B for travelers seeking a quieter, boutique stay and close access to waterfront sights.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Bayfront Westcott House St Augustine B&B |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Gilded‑Age resort with full services and event space | Small, Victorian bayfront bed‑and‑breakfast; intimate and highly rated |
| Location | Heart of historic downtown; steps from Flagler College and St. George Street | Centrally located on the bayfront, within a 10‑minute walk of Lightner Museum and Flagler College |
| Size (rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 16 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check‑in age 21 | Adults‑only property (no guests under 18) |
| Pools / beach access | Heated outdoor pool plus a separate children’s pool; beach concierge and scheduled shuttle to St. Augustine Beach | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Starbucks/Café Cordova (on site) | Free cooked‑to‑order breakfast; room service during limited hours; no on‑site full restaurant listed |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa (multiple treatment rooms, Moroccan‑villa design); fitness center (24/7 access cited on some pages) | Onsite massages available by reservation; limited front desk hours |
| Known for | Historic architecture, event/wedding spaces, downtown location and resort amenities | Bayfront setting and exceptionally high guest ratings |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (fee); resort fee includes shuttle and beach access | Free self parking nearby; front desk with limited hours |
| Guest rating / stars | Full‑service resort (star rating varies by source) | 3.5 stars; guest rating 9.8/10 |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of historic downtown, a short walk to Flagler College, Lightner Museum and St. George Street.
Best for guests who want immediate access to downtown museums, shops and organized tours.
Bayfront Westcott House sits on the Matanzas River/bayfront in the historic district, within easy walking distance of downtown museums and St. George Street.
Best for travelers who want waterfront proximity while staying in the historic district.
Casa Monica offers a broad range of guest rooms and suites across a large historic property.
Choose Casa Monica when you need more room types, suites, or accessible options for families or groups.
Bayfront Westcott House is a small B&B with 16 air‑conditioned rooms and private bathrooms.
Good choice if you want a compact, boutique room inventory and a quieter stay.
Casa Monica has multiple on‑site dining venues covering coffee, casual poolside drinks and a full dinner restaurant.
Better for travelers who want varied, full‑service dining options without leaving the property.
Bayfront Westcott House offers complimentary cooked‑to‑order breakfast and a daily reception; limited room service hours are available.
Ideal if a high‑quality included breakfast and a social reception are priorities; downtown dining is steps away.
Casa Monica provides a heated outdoor pool, a children's pool, and a beach concierge with shuttle service to St. Augustine Beach.
Pick Casa Monica for on‑site pool time plus organized beach access for families and groups.
Bayfront Westcott House's main appeal is its bayfront location and small‑property atmosphere.
Choose Bayfront Westcott House for waterfront scenery and easy access to boat tours and bay activities.
Casa Monica combines a full‑service spa and an active social schedule at its bars and lounges, plus extensive event space.
Better for travelers who want a full spa, organized nightlife options, and sizeable event/wedding facilities.
Bayfront Westcott House provides limited front‑desk hours with concierge‑type services and arranged guest activities.
Great for guests who value quiet evenings, personalized touches, and arranging local tours from a small property.

Casa Monica — pool, children’s pool, suites, and large event/wedding spaces.

Bayfront Westcott House — small, intimate B&B right on the Matanzas River with excellent guest ratings.

Casa Monica — multiple restaurants, a lobby lounge with live music, and poolside bar.

Bayfront Westcott House — very high traveler rating (9.8) and a boutique B&B experience.
Both are in the historic district and within easy walking distance of St. George Street; Casa Monica sits on a main downtown block, while Bayfront Westcott House is a short walk to the same attractions from the bay.
No — supplier information states guests under 18 are not permitted; it operates as an adults‑oriented property.
Not published — supplier listing does not list an on‑site pool.
Casa Monica has an on‑site Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms; Bayfront Westcott House offers onsite massages by reservation but does not list a full spa facility in the supplier details.
Casa Monica — the resort has multiple ballrooms, pavilion and pool‑deck venues with capacities for both small and large events; Bayfront Westcott House is a small B&B and does not list large event spaces.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·