
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers after historic character, an in-house spa and a family-friendly pool setup steps from St. George Street and Flagler College.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a restored 1888 Gilded-Age landmark in downtown St. Augustine with a heated outdoor pool, children's pool and an on-site Poseidon Spa — a good read for travelers who want historic character, on-site spa services, and easy walking access to the city’s main sights. Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront is a mid-range Hilton on the Matanzas River waterfront, aimed at travelers who prefer a recognizable brand, bayfront views, and conference facilities within a short walk of St. George Street.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for travelers after historic character, an in-house spa and a family-friendly pool setup steps from St. George Street and Flagler College.

Best for guests who want bay or marina views, a central Historic District address with Hilton loyalty/standards, and larger meeting space.
When Casa Monica wins: Choose Casa Monica if you value historic architecture, an on-site full-service spa (Poseidon Spa), a heated pool plus a dedicated children's pool, and walkable access to Flagler College, Lightner Museum and St. George Street.
When Hilton wins: Choose the Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront if you want waterfront/bay views, a Hilton-branded experience with conference facilities and rooftop terrace options close to Castillo de San Marcos and the marina.
Bottom line: Both hotels put you in the heart of St. Augustine’s Historic District within a short walk of major attractions — pick Casa Monica for history, spa and a more boutique, resort-feel stay; pick the Hilton for bayfront views, business or event-friendly facilities and a familiar brand standard.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Gilded-Age landmark with Moroccan/Mediterranean design cues | Contemporary midscale Hilton located on the Matanzas River waterfront |
| Location (to St. George St / Flagler College) | Steps (1-minute walk) to Flagler College and St. George Street | Within a 5-minute walk of St. George Street and Flagler College |
| Size (rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 72 guestrooms |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool, hot tub, and a dedicated children's pool | Outdoor pool and hot tub |
| Spa | Poseidon Spa — full-service spa with ~3,000 sq ft, multiple treatments and treatment rooms | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Starbucks/Café Cordova, plus Raintree Restaurant nearby | Aviles Restaurant (on-site) plus a bar/lounge and room service (limited hours) |
| Business & events | Extensive event spaces (Casa Monica Ballroom, Flagler Ballroom, Sultan’s Pavilion) and multiple meeting rooms | Large conference space (17,222 sq ft) and 3 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly; children welcome; children 18 and under stay free in existing bedding | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Parking & transfers | Valet parking (fee); included beach shuttle/concierge access via resort fee | Valet parking (surcharge); concierge services and luggage storage |
| Fitness | 24-hour or open-hours fitness center (sources vary) with cardio and weights; included with resort fee | 24-hour fitness facilities and wheelchair-accessible fitness center |
Casa Monica sits in the very center of the historic district, a 1-minute walk from Flagler College and steps from St. George Street.
Pick Casa Monica if you want the shortest walk to downtown attractions and museums.
Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront sits on the Matanzas River waterfront and is still within easy walking distance of the historic core.
Pick the Hilton if a bayfront view matters but you still want to be within walking distance of the main sights.
Casa Monica’s rooms and suites emphasize period character and range from standard rooms to multi-bedroom suites.
Choose Casa Monica for larger-suite options and historic-room character.
Hilton’s 72 guestrooms include city-view, balcony and bay-view room types aimed at travelers wanting river views or standard Hilton room features.
Choose the Hilton for fewer rooms but more bay- or balcony-view-focused room inventory and standard Hilton amenities.
Casa Monica offers multiple on-site dining spots anchored by Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar and a pool lounge.
Pick Casa Monica if you want a variety of on-site dining options, including a notable signature restaurant and a pool bar.
Hilton offers on-site Aviles Restaurant and a bar/lounge, plus limited room service hours.
Pick the Hilton if you want straightforward bayfront dining with easy access to nearby downtown restaurants.
Casa Monica has a heated outdoor pool, hot tub and a separate children's pool, plus beach concierge and shuttle service.
Choose Casa Monica for family-friendly pool options and included beach shuttle/concierge access.
Hilton has an outdoor pool and hot tub and is sited directly on the Matanzas River for waterfront views.
Choose the Hilton if a river/marina setting and bay-view rooms are priorities.
Casa Monica emphasizes on-site wellness with its Poseidon Spa plus an active lobby bar with live music.
Pick Casa Monica if an on-site full-service spa and a lively hotel bar are important to your stay.
Hilton provides fitness facilities, a rooftop terrace and a bar/lounge for evening drinks.
Pick the Hilton for straightforward fitness offerings, a rooftop terrace and easy access to evening waterfront views.

Casa Monica — original 1888 architecture, period details and Gilded-Age presence in downtown.

Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront — rooms and public areas face the Matanzas River and marina.

Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms and dedicated Quiet Room.

Hilton — large conference space (17,222 sq ft) and meeting-room inventory suited to events.
Both are within easy walking distance, but Casa Monica is steps away and is the shorter walk.
Casa Monica explicitly lists a children's pool and family-friendly policies; Hilton welcomes all ages but does not advertise a children's pool in the supplied listing.
Casa Monica has the Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms. Hilton’s supplier listing does not publish a full-service spa.
Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront sits on the Matanzas River and offers bay-view and bayfront balcony rooms; Casa Monica is downtown rather than directly on the river.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·