
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want full-service on-site dining, a dedicated spa (Poseidon Spa), heated outdoor pool and children’s pool, and larger event/wedding spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a landmark 1888 Gilded‑Age resort in downtown St. Augustine with a full spa, pool complex, and multiple on‑site restaurants — good for families, couples, and event guests who want historic architecture and full services. Casablanca Inn on the Bay is a smaller, bayfront historic inn steps from the waterfront and St. George Street — good for travelers who want a recognizable independent inn with a waterfront feel and an intimate scale.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want full-service on-site dining, a dedicated spa (Poseidon Spa), heated outdoor pool and children’s pool, and larger event/wedding spaces.

Best for travelers who want a compact, recognizable independent inn with a bayfront location and an intimate downtown experience close to St. George Street.
When Casa Monica wins: choose Casa Monica if you want more on‑site services (full spa, multiple food & drink venues including Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar and a Starbucks, a heated outdoor pool plus a children’s pool, 24‑hour fitness, and substantial event/wedding space).
When Casablanca Inn on the Bay wins: choose Casablanca Inn on the Bay if you prefer a smaller, bayfront independent inn within steps of Matanzas River and downtown attractions and you don’t need a full spa or resort‑scale amenities.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the more service‑rich, larger resort option in the historic core; Casablanca Inn on the Bay is a compact, waterfront historic inn for guests prioritizing location and a smaller property feel.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Casablanca Inn on the Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded‑Age landmark resort blending historic architecture with resort services | Small, bayfront historic inn with intimate, independent‑inn character |
| Location (downtown) | Heart of historic downtown; steps from Flagler College, St. George Street, Lightner Museum | |
| Size | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 22 guestrooms |
| Adult/child policy | All‑ages resort; children welcome (children 18 and younger stay free in same room with parent/guardian) | All ages; not adults‑only (minimum check‑in age 21 noted in some channels for registration) |
| Pools / beach access | Heated outdoor pool, children's pool, hot tub; beach concierge and shuttle service to St. Augustine Beach | No on‑site pool published; bayfront location on Matanzas River (water access/view) |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa on‑site with multiple treatment rooms, robes/slippers, Quiet Room; 24‑hour or extended fitness center (hours vary by source) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Café/Starbucks on property; full dinner and brunch options | One on‑site restaurant and one bar/lounge; cooked‑to‑order breakfast available for a fee |
| Known for | Historic Gilded‑Age architecture, large event and wedding spaces, full‑service resort amenities | Bayfront historic inn within walking distance of major downtown sights |
| Parking | Valet parking available (surcharge; rates vary by source) | Free self parking nearby; offsite parking reservations required |
| Connectivity | High‑speed internet included via resort fee (Wi‑Fi in rooms/public areas) | |
Casa Monica sits in the middle of the historic core, a short walk from Flagler College, St. George Street and nearby museums.
Best if you want to be in the historic downtown hub with easy access to attractions and tour departures.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay puts you steps from Matanzas River and a short walk to St. George Street and Castillo de San Marcos.
Best if you want a compact downtown stay with immediate bayfront proximity.
Casa Monica offers a broad mix of rooms and suites across 125–138 guestrooms, including multi‑bedroom suites.
Better for groups or families who may need suites, accessible rooms, or rollaway/crib options.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay has 22 guestrooms in a small historic inn footprint with varied room naming and some balcony/patio options.
Better for travelers looking for a smaller, more intimate set of room choices close to the water.
Casa Monica has several on‑site dining options ranging from a signature chophouse to a pool bar and Starbucks café.
Choose Casa Monica if you want varied on‑site dining and late‑night bar options.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay lists one restaurant and one bar/lounge; cooked‑to‑order breakfasts are available for a fee.
Good if you plan to explore downtown restaurants but still want convenient in‑house options.
Casa Monica offers a heated outdoor pool, a separate children’s pool, and a hot tub, plus beach concierge/shuttle to the ocean.
Pick Casa Monica when you want resort‑style pool amenities and organized beach access.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay’s highlight is its immediate bayfront location on Matanzas River rather than an on‑site pool.
Pick Casablanca Inn on the Bay if waterfront proximity is more important than on‑site pool facilities.
Casa Monica includes the Poseidon Spa, a full fitness center and an active lobby/lounge scene with weekend entertainment.
Choose Casa Monica for a full spa experience and on‑site evening entertainment options.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay is quieter by scale; its listing highlights proximity to nightlife and attractions but does not list a spa or fitness center.
Pick Casablanca Inn on the Bay if you want a low‑service, quiet base within walking distance of downtown nightlife.

Casa Monica — on‑site Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms and spa packages.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay — small bayfront inn steps from the Matanzas River and downtown sights.

Casa Monica — children’s pool, family‑friendly policies and large event/wedding ballrooms.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay — an independent, recognizable downtown inn with an intimate scale.
Casa Monica — it has a heated outdoor pool plus a dedicated children’s pool and family‑friendly room and dining policies.
Casablanca Inn on the Bay — it is a bayfront inn right on Matanzas River with easy waterfront access and views.
Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa and a fitness center are both on site; Casablanca Inn on the Bay does not publish a spa or fitness facility.
No — both properties list breakfast as available for a fee (Casa Monica offers continental breakfast for a fee; Casablanca Inn offers cooked‑to‑order breakfast for a surcharge).
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·