
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want a full‑service historic downtown resort with spa treatments, multiple restaurants/bars and event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a full-service, historic Gilded‑Age resort in downtown St. Augustine with an on-site spa, multiple dining venues and pool facilities — good for travelers who want resort amenities within walking distance of the city's sights. Old Powder House Inn is a smaller traditional historic bed-and-breakfast steps from Flagler College and St. George Street — good for travelers who prefer a compact, characterful stay and complimentary breakfast.
Updated · about 0.1 km apart

Best for travelers who want a full‑service historic downtown resort with spa treatments, multiple restaurants/bars and event spaces.

Best for travelers who want a small-scale, characterful bed‑and‑breakfast within steps of Flagler College and St. George Street.
When Casa Monica wins: choose Casa Monica if you want resort conveniences in downtown — a full spa (Poseidon Spa), several on-site dining options (Cordova Coastal Chophouse, pool lounge, Starbucks), a heated outdoor pool plus a children’s pool, and sizable event/wedding space.
When Old Powder House Inn wins: pick Old Powder House Inn if you prefer a quieter, small‑property experience with historic character, a very central walking location and a complimentary full breakfast included each morning.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the choice for amenity-rich family stays, spa visits and events; Old Powder House Inn is the choice for a compact, heritage B&B stay right in the heart of the historic district.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Old Powder House Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded‑Age landmark resort with resort‑style amenities and event spaces | Traditional historic bed‑and‑breakfast with a small, intimate scale |
| Location (downtown) | Steps from Flagler College, Lightner Museum and St. George Street | Centrally located, steps from Flagler College and St. George Street |
| Size | Large resort (about 125–138 rooms, multiple suites) | Small inn (9 guestrooms) |
| Audience | All ages — family‑friendly (children welcome) | All ages — not adults‑only |
| Pools / beach access | Heated outdoor pool, children's pool; beach concierge & shuttle service to St. Augustine Beach | No on‑site pool listed; beach is several miles away (not on‑site) |
| Spa & fitness | Poseidon Spa on site (multiple treatment rooms) and a fitness center | No on‑site spa or fitness center published |
| Dining & bars | Multiple on‑site options: Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Starbucks/Café Cordova; additional nearby restaurants | No on‑site restaurant listed; complimentary full breakfast served daily |
| Parking | Valet parking available (fee) | Free self parking available |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair‑accessible paths, accessible pool/elevator and accessible guest services (many accessible features) | Wheelchair accessible – no; upper floors reachable by stairs only |
| Known for | Spa, historic ballroom/event space, family amenities and downtown convenience | Heritage character, central walkable location and complimentary breakfast |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, within steps of Flagler College, Lightner Museum and St. George Street.
Best if you want resort amenities without leaving the historic downtown walkable area.
Old Powder House Inn is centrally located on Cordova Street, just steps from Flagler College and a short walk to St. George Street.
Best if you want a compact stay that prioritizes immediate walkability to downtown sights.
Casa Monica offers a broad room mix ranging from standard rooms to multi‑bedroom suites, with accessible options.
Better for larger parties, families and guests who need accessible rooms or suite space.
Old Powder House Inn offers a small number of named guest rooms with a historic B&B layout.
Better for travelers who prefer a small, characterful room inventory and a B&B atmosphere.
Casa Monica provides several on‑site dining venues for meals and drinks throughout the day.
Choose Casa Monica if you want multiple dining and bar choices without leaving the hotel.
Old Powder House Inn does not list an on‑site full restaurant but includes a complimentary full breakfast daily.
Pick Old Powder House Inn for a simpler stay where breakfast is included and downtown dining is a short walk away.
Casa Monica has guest pools and beach support for an active‑oriented stay.
Great for families and guests who plan to use a pool or want assisted beach access.
Old Powder House Inn’s supplier listing does not include a pool or beach concierge.
Better for travelers who plan to explore the historic district on foot rather than spend time at a hotel pool or beach facility.
Casa Monica includes a full‑service spa, a fitness center and an evening lounge with live music on weekends.
Choose Casa Monica if you want a full spa/facility program and an on‑property evening scene.
Old Powder House Inn offers a quiet, small‑property experience without a published spa, fitness center or nightly entertainment.
Better for travelers who expect a quiet stay and will use downtown venues for nightlife or wellness.

Casa Monica — on‑site Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms and a fitness center.

Old Powder House Inn — small B&B scale and immediate proximity to Flagler College and St. George Street.

Casa Monica — heated outdoor pool, separate children’s pool and family‑friendly policies.

Old Powder House Inn — complimentary full breakfast served daily.
Both are essentially steps from St. George Street, but Old Powder House Inn and Casa Monica are about 0.1 km apart on Cordova Street.
Casa Monica — it has the on‑site Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms and a full menu of services; Old Powder House Inn does not list a spa.
Old Powder House Inn includes a complimentary full breakfast daily. Casa Monica offers breakfast on property for a fee (continental options typically around $15–20 per person).
Casa Monica publishes multiple accessible features (paths, pool access, accessible rooms/elevator). Old Powder House Inn’s listing notes it is not wheelchair accessible and upper floors are stairs only.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·