
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want resort amenities (spa, pool, on-site restaurants) in the middle of the historic district.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a landmark, full-service downtown St. Augustine resort with a spa, heated outdoor pool and multiple on-site dining options; read this if you want historic Gilded-Age surroundings with resort amenities. Penny Farthing Inn is a small, classic bed-and-breakfast steps from St. George Street; read this if you prefer a locally run inn and a quieter, more intimate stay near the city’s main attractions.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want resort amenities (spa, pool, on-site restaurants) in the middle of the historic district.

Best for travelers who want a small, independently run bed-and-breakfast within an easy walk of St. George Street and Flagler College.
When Casa Monica Resort & Spa wins: choose Casa Monica if you want resort-style facilities (Poseidon Spa, heated outdoor pool and children’s pool), multiple on-site dining and a larger hotel with event/wedding spaces.
When Penny Farthing Inn wins: choose Penny Farthing if you want a small, classic B&B experience, free daily full breakfast, and rooms with historic charm a short walk from major sights.
Bottom line: both are centrally located in St. Augustine’s historic core; pick Casa Monica for a full-service, amenity-rich stay and Penny Farthing Inn for a quieter, intimate B&B close to the attractions.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Penny Farthing Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, historic Gilded-Age resort with resort amenities and event spaces | Small, classic bed-and-breakfast with a home-style feel |
| Location (historic downtown) | Steps from St. George Street, Flagler College and Lightner Museum | |
| Size (rooms) | 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | 9 rooms |
| Check-in minimum age | 21 (guests under 21 may check in with a parent/guardian) | 18 (check-in minimum 18 years per supplier listing) |
| Pools / water access | Heated outdoor pool, children’s pool, hot tub; beach concierge + shuttle to St. Augustine Beach | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, on-site Starbucks/Café Cordova | No on-site restaurant listed; complimentary full breakfast served daily |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa (treatments, manicure/pedicure area, Quiet Room); fitness center on-site | Not published |
| Known for | Gilded-Age landmark hotel with ballroom and extensive event space | Classic B&B experience within walking distance of major historic sites |
| Parking | Valet parking available (fee) | Free self parking / limited spaces |
| Breakfast | Continental breakfast available for a fee (~$15–$20/person) | Complimentary full breakfast served daily from 8:30–9:30 AM |
Casa Monica sits in the historic core with immediate access to St. George Street and several museums.
Choose Casa Monica if you want the widest on-site services while staying in the exact heart of the historic district.
Penny Farthing Inn is a small B&B located on Cedar Street within easy walking distance of the same downtown attractions.
Pick Penny Farthing for a simple, central stay when you plan to spend most of your time exploring on foot.
Casa Monica offers a wide range of room types and multiple suites across a large property.
Casa Monica suits families or groups needing more room-type choices and accessibility options.
Penny Farthing Inn has nine individually named rooms with a B&B scale and character.
Penny Farthing is best for travelers who prefer a small inventory of unique rooms and a B&B layout.
Casa Monica has multiple on-site dining venues that cover coffee, casual poolside drinks and full evening meals.
Choose Casa Monica if you want several on-site dining and bar options without leaving the property.
Penny Farthing’s offering centers on the full complimentary breakfast included with a stay.
Penny Farthing is a good pick if a hearty included breakfast and a quieter evenings-at-the-inn routine matter more than on-site dining variety.
Casa Monica provides a heated outdoor pool, a children’s pool, hot tub and beach concierge services.
If pool time or beach access via concierge/shuttle matters, Casa Monica clearly offers more on-site and partner services.
Penny Farthing Inn does not list a pool or on-site beach services in the supplied facts.
Penny Farthing is for travelers who prioritize location and B&B character over pool or beach services.
Casa Monica offers a full-service spa and an evening lounge with live music on weekends.
Casa Monica suits travelers who want spa services and an active on-site evening scene.
Penny Farthing Inn focuses on a quieter, intimate stay; no spa or nightlife venues are listed.
Choose Penny Farthing for a low-key stay; for spa or nightlife options, you’ll use nearby downtown venues.

Casa Monica — spa, heated outdoor pool, poolside bar, multiple restaurants and event spaces.

Penny Farthing Inn — just nine rooms, complimentary full breakfast and a cozy, independent feel.

Casa Monica — children’s pool, family-friendly policies and roomy suite options.

Penny Farthing Inn — central location, free full breakfast and free self parking (limited).
Both are within easy walking distance of St. George Street; Casa Monica is essentially steps away and Penny Farthing is a short walk as well.
Penny Farthing Inn includes a complimentary full breakfast. Casa Monica offers continental breakfast for a fee (about $15–$20 per person) unless a package says otherwise.
Casa Monica has an on-site Poseidon Spa and a heated outdoor pool with a separate children’s pool; the Penny Farthing supplier listing does not publish a spa or pool.
Casa Monica is explicitly family-friendly and lists facilities for children. Penny Farthing Inn is not adults-only—its minimum check-in age is 18—so families can stay, but it is a small B&B with stairs and limited space.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·