
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for history, walking to St. Augustine attractions, full-service dining and a spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a full-service, historic downtown St. Augustine hotel with an on-site spa and multiple dining venues; read this if you want a central base for sightseeing and hotel amenities. Floridays is a small Butler Beach vacation-home style property with private-pool room types; read this if you want a simpler, beach-area stay closer to Anastasia Island.
Updated · about 8.6 mi apart

Best for history, walking to St. Augustine attractions, full-service dining and a spa.

Best for a small, beach-area rental with a private pool option and easy access to Butler Beach.
When Casa Monica wins: Choose Casa Monica if you want to stay in the heart of old St. Augustine within walking distance of Flagler College, St. George Street and museums, plus on-site dining, a heated outdoor pool, a children’s pool and a staffed spa.
When Floridays wins: Choose Floridays if you want a quieter, beach-area base (Butler Beach) with a private-pool rental feel and a short drive to Anastasia State Park and St. Augustine Beach.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the pick for travelers seeking downtown location, hotel services and event space; Floridays is a simple, small-property alternative nearer the beaches, best for travelers prioritizing a beachside neighborhood over downtown walkability.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Floridays |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded‑Age historic full-service resort with formal public spaces | Small vacation-home style property focused on beach proximity |
| Location | Historic downtown St. Augustine, steps from St. George Street and Flagler College | Butler Beach / Anastasia Island area, a short drive from downtown |
| Size | About 125–138 rooms (sources vary) | Small property; exact room count not published |
| Who it's best for | Sightseeing, families, guests wanting spa and hotel services | Beach-focused travelers who want a private-pool feel and quieter neighborhood |
| Pools / beach access | Heated outdoor pool, dedicated children’s pool; beach concierge and shuttle service to St. Augustine Beach | Outdoor private pool options listed; walking distance to Butler Beach (0.5 km / 0.3 mi) |
| Restaurants & bars | On-site Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge and Starbucks (Cafe Cordova) | Self-catering kitchen in the rental; no published on-site restaurant or bar |
| Spa & wellness | Full‑service Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms, plus fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Historic architecture (1888), downtown location, event & wedding spaces | Butler Beach location and private-pool vacation-home room types |
| Guest rating | Not published | |
| Access & check-in | Standard check-in 4:00 PM; front desk and valet on site | No front desk; guests receive access code by email and private entrance |
Casa Monica sits in the heart of historic downtown St. Augustine, steps from Flagler College and St. George Street.
Pick Casa Monica for maximum access to downtown history, dining and tours.
Floridays is located in Butler Beach on Anastasia Island, closer to the area’s beaches and state park.
Pick Floridays to be nearer to the beach and island parks rather than downtown walkability.
Casa Monica offers a range of guest rooms and suites across 10 named room types.
Choose Casa Monica if you want traditional hotel rooms, suites and hotel services such as housekeeping and concierge.
Floridays lists vacation-home style room types like House, Multiple Beds, Private Pool, Pool View.
Choose Floridays if you want a self-contained unit with kitchen and private-pool style accommodations.
Casa Monica has several on-site outlets for meals, cocktails and coffee.
Casa Monica is better if you want on-site dining and evening drinks without leaving the hotel.
Floridays lists an in-unit kitchen and does not publish dedicated on-site restaurants or bars.
Floridays suits travelers planning to cook or eat locally rather than rely on hotel restaurants.
Casa Monica maintains a heated outdoor pool, a children’s pool and beach concierge services.
Casa Monica is set up for families and hotel guests who want managed pool and beach services.
Floridays lists an outdoor pool and private-pool room types at its Butler Beach address.
Floridays is a straightforward beach-area option if you want private-pool accommodations and beach proximity.
Casa Monica offers a dedicated spa, fitness center and an on-site lounge with weekend live music.
Casa Monica provides full-service spa and on-site evening entertainment for hotel guests.
Floridays does not publish a spa or on-site nightlife; guests rely on nearby beach and town nightlife.
Floridays is better suited to low-key stays; plan off-property visits for spa or nightlife.

Casa Monica — steps from St. George Street, Flagler College and downtown attractions.

Floridays — located in Butler Beach with quick access to Anastasia State Park and St. Augustine Beach.

Casa Monica — full-service Poseidon Spa, fitness center, multiple dining venues and concierge services.

Floridays — room types list private pool and pool-view house options with kitchen facilities.
Casa Monica is in downtown St. Augustine, within walking distance of major attractions. Floridays is in Butler Beach about 8.6 miles from downtown.
Casa Monica operates the Poseidon Spa with multiple treatment rooms. Floridays does not publish an on-site spa.
Floridays is in the Butler Beach area and is very close to the beach; the supplier listing notes beach and Matanzas River proximity.
Casa Monica is family-friendly with a children’s pool and family services; Floridays can work for families who prefer a self-catered beach-area rental.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·