
Casa Monica Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want historic character, on-site fine dining, an extensive event program and a full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Monica Resort & Spa is a historic, full-service downtown St. Augustine resort with multiple restaurants, a full spa, pool and family-friendly facilities; read this if you want a landmark property with on-site dining, event space and a full-service spa. Spark by Hilton St. Augustine Historic District is a value-oriented, branded midscale hotel in the historic core with basic amenities, free continental breakfast and an outdoor pool; read this if you want a convenient, budget-friendly downtown stay close to St. George Street.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want historic character, on-site fine dining, an extensive event program and a full-service spa.

Best for budget-conscious travelers who want a modern, branded downtown stay with simple amenities and a central location.
When Casa Monica wins: choose Casa Monica if you want historic architecture, multiple on-site restaurants and bars (Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Cobalt Lounge, Café Cordova), a full-service Poseidon Spa, larger event/wedding spaces and family-friendly pool facilities including a children's pool.
When Spark wins: choose Spark if you’re after a recognized midscale brand in the heart of the historic district, a smaller simpler property with complimentary continental breakfast and straightforward amenities (outdoor pool, hot tub, sauna) at a lower price point.
Bottom line: Casa Monica is the full-service, historic resort choice for guests wanting dining, spa and event facilities on site; Spark is a practical, value-oriented downtown option for travelers prioritizing location and a basic amenity set.
| Category | Casa Monica Resort & Spa | Spark |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Gilded-Age landmark with Mediterranean/Moorish-inspired interiors, formal dining and a full-service spa. | Contemporary, branded midscale hotel focused on value and basic convenience. |
| Location (historic downtown) | Steps from St. George Street, Flagler College and Lightner Museum (very walkable to downtown attractions). | |
| Size | 125–138 rooms, multiple suites and event spaces. | 51 rooms. |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly (children’s pool; children 18 and younger stay free in existing bedding). | |
| Pools & hot tubs | Heated outdoor pool, separate children's pool, and adjacent hot tub; pool hours published. | Outdoor pool and 1 hot tub; sauna on site. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, Soltana Pool Lounge, Cobalt Lounge and Café Cordova (Starbucks). | Grocery/convenience store on site; complimentary continental breakfast; no signature on-site restaurant published. |
| Spa & wellness | Poseidon Spa — full-service spa with multiple treatment rooms, nail services and scheduled hours. | Not published |
| Known for | Historic Gilded-Age architecture, event/wedding spaces and full-service amenities. | Value-branded downtown option with predictable, basic amenities. |
| Parking & transfers | Valet parking (fee), resort fee includes beach shuttle/concierge access to St. Augustine Beach. | Uncovered self parking available for a surcharge (fee published). |
Both hotels sit in St. Augustine’s historic core; Casa Monica is effectively adjacent to the city’s main sights.
Choose Casa Monica if you want to be in the heart of historic downtown with immediate access to major sights and tour departures.
Spark is also centrally located in the historic district with a short walk to St. George Street and nearby museums.
Choose Spark for an economical downtown base that keeps you steps from the historic district’s main walking routes.
Casa Monica offers a range of rooms and suites across a historic property with accessible and multi-bedroom options.
Casa Monica suits travelers who want a variety of room sizes and historic character, including larger suites for families or groups.
Spark provides simple, air-conditioned rooms with basics like refrigerators and flat-screen TVs.
Spark fits travelers wanting straightforward, accessible rooms and essential in-room features at a smaller property.
Casa Monica provides several on-site dining and drinking options, including a signature chophouse and a lobby lounge.
Casa Monica is the clear choice for on-site evening dining, a dedicated cocktail lounge and poolside bar.
Spark offers a limited on-site food offering focused on convenience and complimentary breakfast.
Spark is suited to guests who prefer a simple complimentary breakfast and convenient snack options rather than full-service dining.
Casa Monica offers a heated outdoor pool area designed for families plus a separate children’s pool and hot tub.
If on-property pool time and family-friendly pool facilities matter, Casa Monica delivers more complete pool amenities.
Spark provides an outdoor pool, a hot tub and a sauna as part of its basic leisure amenities.
Spark covers the essentials — pool, hot tub and sauna — for guests who want basic leisure facilities without the full resort program.
Casa Monica combines a full-service spa and larger nightlife/event offerings with multiple ballrooms and live-music lounge nights.
Casa Monica supports wellness and social events on site — good for spa-goers, wedding parties and groups.
Spark focuses on practical amenities rather than an on-site spa or large event program.
Pick Spark if you need a compact downtown hotel without expectations of spa services or large event facilities.

Casa Monica — Poseidon Spa offers full-service treatments, couples rooms and a Quiet Room.

Spark — branded midscale hotel with complimentary continental breakfast and basic amenities.

Casa Monica — on-site Cordova Coastal Chophouse, Cobalt Lounge and poolside bar provide evening dining and drinks.

Spark — smaller property with essential services and easy pedestrian access to historic attractions.
Both are in the historic core and within a short walk of St. George Street and museums; Casa Monica sits immediately adjacent to several landmarks while Spark is a short walk away.
No on-site full-service spa is published for Spark in the supplier listing; Casa Monica has the Poseidon Spa with published hours and treatments.
Casa Monica is explicitly family-friendly with a children’s pool and family room/suite options; Spark is all-ages but positioned as a midscale, no-frills hotel.
Spark includes a complimentary continental breakfast. Casa Monica offers continental breakfast for a fee (typically around $15–$20) and is not an all-inclusive property.
Explore how Casa Monica Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·